Knack › Guides › Conversations
How to open up to people without oversharing
Questions alone turn a chat into an interview. Closeness grows when both people share, in turns. Here is how much to share, and when.
Questions alone become an interview
Closeness grows when both people share, in turns, a little more each time. Arthur Aron’s well-known 1997 closeness study was built on exactly that.
Later research compared pairs who took turns sharing with pairs where one person did all the talking. The pairs who took turns liked each other more.
So after a question or two, give something of your own.
Which reply shares and hands it back?
Where was it?
A fair question, but it is only a question. He shared something about himself, and nothing came back.
I’m from the city, so I can’t imagine. I hated small towns when I visited. Nothing open, nothing to do...
That is a monologue, and it criticizes where he is from.
Mine had a cow on the town sign. What did you do for fun there?
One small thing about you, the same size as his, and then the turn goes back to him.
Match their depth, then go one step
If they share something small, share something small. If they go a step deeper, you can too.
Sharing far more than they did skips steps and can feel heavy. Never sharing anything keeps them at a distance.
A shape that works: one sentence about you, then a question for them.
He just went a step deeper. What fits?
Oh. Anyway, what do you do for work?
He offered something real and it was dropped. He probably won’t offer again.
My childhood was way worse. My parents...
It turns his moment into a competition and takes the floor.
That sounds hard. I moved a lot as a kid, so I know a bit of that. What changed it for you?
You received it, matched it with one sentence of your own, and gave the turn back.
Try it yourself
Share one small thing about yourself, then ask her a question.
Ways it could sound:
- I can make exactly three dishes, so respect. What went wrong with the risotto?
- I burned pasta once, which shouldn’t be possible. What are you cooking next?
One thing to try today
In your next chat, answer one question with a real detail about yourself before you ask one back.
Reading is not practicing
In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.
Practice it in KnackWhere this comes from: Aron, Melinat, Aron, Vallone & Bator (1997). The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 23(4). Sprecher, Treger, Wondra, Hilaire & Wallpe (2013). Taking turns: Reciprocal self-disclosure promotes liking in initial interactions. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 49(5).