Knack

Knack › Guides › Conversations

The liking gap: people like you more than you think

4 minute read · From the Conversations path in Knack

After talking to someone new, most people guess they were liked less than they really were. Here is the study, and what to do with it.

The liking gap

After talking with someone new, most people guess that the other person liked them less than they really did.

Researchers measured this in 2018. Strangers talked, then each person rated how much they liked the other, and how much they thought the other liked them. People underestimated, again and again. The shyer they were, the bigger the miss.

You had a five-minute chat with a new coworker. Walking away, you replay the moment you lost your words. What does the research suggest?

Less helpfulThey noticed, and it shaped what they think of me.

That is the gap talking. In the study, people's guesses about how they came across were reliably too harsh.

Less helpfulIt depends on whether I was funny.

The study didn't find that you need to perform. Ordinary conversations produced the gap.

This one worksThey liked me more than I'm guessing, and were busy worrying about themselves.

Yes. Both people leave a conversation replaying their own stumbles, not the other person's.

Why it happens

You hear your inner critic. They only hear what you said out loud.

Meanwhile they have their own critic, and it is busy with them. Your memory of the chat is a list of your slips. Theirs is a list of their own.

So when you feel a conversation went badly, treat that as a feeling, not as a report.

PriyaSorry, I talk too much when I’m nervous. Anyway!

Priya is showing you her own liking gap. Which reply helps most?

Less helpfulNo worries.

Polite, but it quietly agrees there was something to forgive, and it ends her story.

Less helpfulHa, same. I’m so awkward.

It feels like bonding, but it moves the attention to you and leaves her story unfinished.

This one worksYou don’t. I was enjoying it. What happened after you got to the airport?

You corrected her harsh guess, then showed you meant it by going back to her story.

Try it yourself

SamHey, good to see you again! How was your weekend?

Assume Sam already likes you. Answer with one real detail, then hand it back with a question.

Ways it could sound:

  • Pretty quiet. I finally fixed my bike. How was yours?
  • Good! I tried a new ramen place and I’m still thinking about it. What did you get up to?

One thing to try today

After your next chat with someone, guess how much they liked you from 1 to 10. Then add two.

Bo the capybara

Reading is not practicing

In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.

Practice it in Knack

Where this comes from: Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom & Clark (2018). The Liking Gap in Conversations: Do People Like Us More Than We Think? Psychological Science, 29(11).

Keep reading

Knack: Social SkillsFree on the App Store
Get