How to bring up a problem without starting a fight
How a hard conversation starts is usually how it goes. Open with what happened, how you feel and what you would like.
How it starts is how it goes
John Gottman’s research with couples found that a conversation that opens with blame tends to end badly, however it goes in the middle. He calls it a harsh start-up.
Marshall Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication offers a softer opening in four parts: what happened, how you feel, what you need, what you’re asking for.
“The dishes have been there since Monday. I get stressed cooking around them. Could you do them tonight?”
Your roommate has left dishes in the sink for the third day. How do you open?
You’re such a slob.
A label. Now the conversation is about whether they’re a slob, not about the dishes.
Say nothing and close the cupboards loudly.
They’ll notice you’re annoyed and have to guess why. Guessing makes people defensive.
The dishes have been in the sink since Monday. I get stressed cooking around them. Could you do them tonight?
A fact, your feeling, and one clear request. There is nothing in it to argue with.
The camera test
Could a camera have recorded what you’re about to say?
“You ignored me” is your reading of it. “You were on your phone while I was talking” is what a camera would show.
Start with the camera version. People argue with interpretations, and they mostly can’t argue with what happened.
Also drop “always” and “never”. They invite one counter-example, and then you’re debating that.
Which of these passes the camera test?
You don’t care about this project.
A camera can’t film caring. That is a conclusion, and they will deny it.
You’re being lazy.
A label about their character. It starts a defence.
You’ve missed the last two check-ins.
Countable and checkable. You can talk about why from here.
Try it yourself
A friend has cancelled on you three times this month, each time an hour before. Raise it with a soft start: what happened, how you feel, what you’d like.
Ways it could sound:
- You’ve cancelled three times this month, about an hour before. I end up feeling like an afterthought. Could you tell me the day before if it’s not going to work?
One thing to try today
Raise one small thing today using: what happened, how you feel, what you’d like.
Reading is not practicing
In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.
Practice it in KnackWhere this comes from: Gottman & Silver (1999). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Crown. Rosenberg (2003). Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life. PuddleDancer Press.