Knack

Knack › Guides › Conversations

How to give a compliment that actually lands

4 minute read · From the Conversations path in Knack

People underestimate how good a compliment feels and overestimate how awkward it is. Make it specific and about a choice the person made.

Most kind thoughts never get said

In these studies, people were asked to give a compliment to someone else. Before doing it, they guessed how the other person would feel.

They underestimated how good the compliment would make the person feel, and overestimated how awkward it would be.

So people hold back kind thoughts that would have landed well. The fix is simple: when you notice something good, say it.

A coworker just gave a clear presentation. Which compliment lands best?

Less helpfulGood job.

Kind, and forgotten in five seconds. It could be said about anything.

Less helpfulYou’re so smart. I could never do that.

It puts you down, so now she has to reassure you instead of enjoying it.

This one worksThe way you explained the budget with that one chart made it click for me.

Specific, about a choice she made, and it tells her what worked. She can use that.

Specific, about a choice, no strings

Compliment what people chose or did: their work, their taste, their effort. Those feel earned. Comments on bodies are riskier and say less.

Then let it sit. A request straight after turns the compliment into a payment.

When you receive one, “Thank you, that means a lot” is enough. Arguing with a compliment tells the person their judgment is off.

JoI love your jacket, by the way.

How do you take the compliment?

Less helpfulThis old thing? It’s falling apart.

It tells Jo her taste is wrong. She was trying to give you something.

Less helpfulYours is nicer.

An instant return sounds automatic. Take yours first.

This one worksThank you! I found it secondhand and got lucky.

You accepted it and gave a small detail back, which keeps the conversation going.

Try it yourself

Your friend Tara cooked dinner for six people and it was great. Give her one specific compliment.

Ways it could sound:

  • Tara, that sauce was incredible. You made cooking for six look easy.
  • Everyone went quiet when the food came out. That’s the best review a dinner can get.

One thing to try today

Give one specific compliment today, out loud, to the person it’s about.

Bo the capybara

Reading is not practicing

In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.

Practice it in Knack

Where this comes from: Boothby & Bohns (2021). Why a Simple Act of Kindness Is Not as Simple as It Seems: Underestimating the Positive Impact of Our Compliments on Others. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 47(5). Zhao & Epley (2021). Insufficiently Complimentary?: Underestimating the Positive Impact of Compliments Creates a Barrier to Expressing Them. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 121(2).

Keep reading

Knack: Social SkillsFree on the App Store
Get