Knack

Knack › Guides › Conversations

How to have deeper conversations and get past small talk

4 minute read · From the Conversations path in Knack

People expect deeper questions to feel awkward and they feel less awkward than predicted. Here is how to go one level deeper at a time.

Deeper is less awkward than you expect

In a series of experiments, pairs of strangers were given deeper questions to discuss, such as what they were most grateful for.

Beforehand, they expected it to be awkward. Afterwards, they reported less awkwardness, more connection and more happiness than they had predicted.

The researchers’ explanation: we underestimate how much other people care about what we have to say.

SamWork’s fine. Busy. You know how it is.

Which question goes one level deeper without prying?

Less helpfulHow many hours a week is that?

Another fact. You’ll get a number, and then you’re back where you started.

Less helpfulAre you happy with your life?

That’s several levels at once. Deeper works one step at a time.

This one worksWhat’s been the best part of it lately?

It moves from a fact to an opinion, and it’s easy to answer at whatever depth he likes.

The ladder

Think of three rungs: facts, then opinions, then feelings and values.

“Where do you live?” is a fact. “What do you like about it?” is an opinion. “Where would you live if nothing held you back?” gets at what matters to them.

Go up one rung at a time. If a question feels like a lot to ask, answer it yourself first. That shows it’s safe.

RosaWe just moved out to the suburbs. It’s quieter.

Go up one rung.

Less helpfulHow many bedrooms?

A fact. It keeps you on the first rung.

Less helpfulDo you regret it?

It asks her to defend a big decision to someone she’s just chatting with.

This one worksWhat do you miss about the city, if anything?

It asks for her opinion, and “if anything” lets her say “nothing” without it being awkward.

Try it yourself

BenI’ve been a nurse for twelve years now.

Ask something one level deeper than the facts.

Ways it could sound:

  • What’s kept you in it for twelve years?
  • What’s a day at work you still think about?

One thing to try today

Ask one person a question about what they think or feel, instead of a fact.

Bo the capybara

Reading is not practicing

In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.

Practice it in Knack

Where this comes from: Kardas, Kumar & Epley (2022). Overly Shallow?: Miscalibrated Expectations Create a Barrier to Deeper Conversation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 122(3).

Keep reading

Knack: Social SkillsFree on the App Store
Get