Knack › Guides › Conversations
How to start a conversation with a stranger
People predict that talking to a stranger will go badly, and they are wrong. You do not need a line. You need one thing you can both see.
Strangers are nicer than you predict
Researchers asked Chicago train commuters to predict how a ride would go if they talked to the stranger next to them. Most predicted it would be worse than sitting in silence.
Then some commuters were asked to actually do it. Their ride was more pleasant than the silent one.
In another study, people who had a short, friendly exchange with their barista left the coffee shop in a better mood than people who kept it quick and efficient.
You’re in a long line at a food truck. The person next to you is reading the menu. Which opener works?
Hi, I’m Sam. What’s your name?
Nothing wrong with it, but a name with no reason to talk puts them on the spot. The shared situation gives you the reason.
Say nothing. They probably want to be left alone.
That is the exact prediction the train study found to be wrong, for both people.
Have you eaten here before? I can’t decide.
You’re both in the same situation, so there is an obvious reason to speak, and an easy question to answer.
What you both see, plus a question
You don’t need a line. You need one thing you can both see and a question about it: the line, the weather, the music, the food.
Keep it about the shared thing, not about them. “Great playlist in here” is easy to answer. A comment on how someone looks is not.
If you get a short answer, smile and leave it. An opener is an offer. They’re allowed to say no.
At a friend’s birthday, someone is standing alone by the bookshelf.
You look lonely.
It puts a label on them in front of a stranger. Even if it’s true, nobody wants to confirm it.
So, what do you do?
Fine a minute in. As a first line it’s an interview question with no warm-up.
That’s a serious book collection. Spotted anything good?
You joined them in what they were already doing. That’s the lowest-pressure way in.
Try it yourself
You’re in an elevator with a neighbor who is carrying a huge plant. Open with what’s in front of you.
Ways it could sound:
- That’s a serious plant. Where is it going to live?
- Need a hand with that? What kind is it?
One thing to try today
Make one comment about a shared situation to someone you don’t know today.
Reading is not practicing
In Knack you answer these yourself, type your own replies and practice whole conversations. This is one of 32 lessons.
Practice it in KnackWhere this comes from: Epley & Schroeder (2014). Mistakenly Seeking Solitude. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143(5). Sandstrom & Dunn (2014). Is Efficiency Overrated? Minimal Social Interactions Lead to Belonging and Positive Affect. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 5(4).